Ep. 72 Transforming Peer Review: From Punitive to Productive with Dr. Maggie Mueller

Peer review can be a daunting process as a physician, but there are ways to focus the process on constructive feedback and quality improvement rather than criticism and punishment. In this episode of the BackTable OBGYN Podcast, host Dr. Amy Park welcomes urogynecologist Dr. Maggie Mueller to discuss how we can improve the peer review process in the field of obstetrics and gynecology. --- SYNPOSIS Dr. Mueller delves into her personal involvement in peer review, the challenges faced by providers, and the importance of these processes. Key topics include shifting from a punitive to a quality improvement focus, best practices for peer review committees, the integration of human and system factors, the role of multidisciplinary teams, and transparency. The conversation also highlights the ethical considerations and the impact of peer review on provider well-being, emphasizing the need for structured support systems. Dr. Mueller shares insights into the future trends in peer review, advocating for higher physician involvement and leadership in creating more effective and transparent processes. --- TIMESTAMPS 00:00 - Introduction 02:21 - Diving into Peer Review 04:14 - The Peer Review Process Explained 07:07 - Challenges and Improvements in Peer Review 13:14 - Changing the Culture Around Peer Review 21:14 - Moving Away from a Punitive Mindset 25:12 - Education to Become a Reviewer 31:39 - Legal Considerations 32:42 - Ethical Considerations 38:31 - Future Trends in Peer Review 41:20 - Closing Remarks