Jim Minton - Place-based philanthropy in London

Giving Thought - A podcast by Giving Thought

In episode 58 we talk to Jim Minton, CEO of Toynbee Hall- the UK's oldest university settlement and an East End of London institution that has also played a key role in wider social reforms. We discuss the role of local civil society organisations and the opportunities and challenges that come with place-based philanthropy. Including:

  • The history of Toynbee Hall
  • Are enough charities today playing a role as drivers of social reform?
  • Have recent changes such as the Lobbying Act or the use of advocacy clauses in grant contracts made this harder?
  • Can the successes of place-based initiatives inform activities or policymaking at a regional or national level? How can organisations based in one place ensure they ‘influence upwards’?
  • Is “place” more complex than it is sometimes presented? I.e. at what geographic level do we feel a sense of belonging or identity?
  • How do you coordinate philanthropy and voluntary action in a particular place without stifling it?
  • Are place-based organisations particularly well-suited to adopting participatory approaches?
  • What is the particular importance of shared physical space and community buildings in a local area?
  • Does taking a place-based, rather than cause-based approach make it easier to address the multiple, cross-cutting needs of people and communities?
  • Do you think people and communities always have the best answers to their own problems, or do they sometimes need organisations to act for them in their own best interest?
  • What role can philanthropy and voluntary action play in building bridging social capital, bringing diverse communities together or fostering wider civic engagement?

 

Related Links