Karmen Smith & Lottie Spencer | 49

Lottie Spencer & Karmen Smith were both single moms and neighbors. One day in 1995, their two kids got off the school bus & walked into Karmen's apartment to find a horrific scene. It seemed like a cut & dry case since there had been a series of very bizarre events involving a scorned stalker, but 6 months after a verdict was read, a huge bomb is dropped.    Join our Patreon for bonus episodes and merch and follow us on TikTok and Instagram and visit our website for merch.