The Glenlivet Caribbean Reserve (This review might get pulled!)

We finally got our hands on the new Glenlivet Caribbean Reserve Rum Finish that we've been hearing about.  We're not strangers to The Glenlivet line and really appreciate the history and what they produce.  This bottle, however, was a bit of bummer and only one of us gave it a good review.  Which one was it?  Does anyone want to guess?  :-)