Breandan Considine on Neuro Symbolic AI, Coding AIs and AI Timelines

Breandan Considine is a PhD student at the School of Computer Science at McGill University, under the supervision of Jin Guo and Xujie Si). There, he is building tools to help developers locate and reason about software artifacts, by learning to read and write code. I met Breandan while doing my "scale is all you need" series of interviews at Mila, where he surprised me by sitting down for two hours to discuss AGI timelines, augmenting developers with AI and neuro symbolic AI. A fun fact that many noticed while watching the "Scale Is All You Need change my mind" video is that he kept his biking hat most of the time during the interview, since he was close to leaving when we talked. All of the conversation below is real, but note that since I was not prepared to talk for so long, my camera ran out of battery and some of the video footage on Youtube is actually AI generated (Brendan consented to this). Disclaimer: when talking to people in this podcast I try to sometimes invite guests who share different inside views about existential risk from AI so that everyone in the AI community can talk to each other more and coordinate more effectively. Breandan is overall much more optimistic about the potential risks from AI than a lot of people working in AI Alignement research, but I think he is quite articulate in his position, even though I disagree with many of his assumptions. I believe his point of view is important to understand what software engineers and Symbolic reasoning researchers think of deep learning progress. Transcript: https://theinsideview.ai/breandan Youtube: ⁠https://youtu.be/Bo6jO7MIsIU⁠ Host: https://twitter.com/MichaelTrazzi Breandan: https://twitter.com/breandan OUTLINE (00:00) Introduction(01:16) Do We Need Symbolic Reasoning to Get To AGI?(05:41) Merging Symbolic Reasoning & Deep Learning for Powerful AI Systems(10:57) Blending Symbolic Reasoning & Machine Learning Elegantly(15:15) Enhancing Abstractions & Safety in Machine Learning(21:28) AlphaTensor's Applicability May Be Overstated(24:31) AI Safety, Alignment & Encoding Human Values in Code(29:56) Code Research: Moral, Information & Software Aspects(34:17) Automating Programming & Self-Improving AI(36:25) Debunking AI "Monsters" & World Domination Complexities(43:22) Neural Networks: Limits, Scaling Laws & Computation Challenges(59:54) Real-world Software Development vs. Competitive Programming(1:02:59) Measuring Programmer Productivity & Evaluating AI-generated Code(1:06:09) Unintended Consequences, Reward Misspecification & AI-Human Symbiosis(1:16:59) AI's Superior Intelligence: Impact, Self-Improvement & Turing Test Predictions(1:23:52) AI Scaling, Optimization Trade-offs & Economic Viability(1:29:02) Metrics, Misspecifications & AI's Rich Task Diversity(1:30:48) Federated Learning & AI Agent Speed Comparisons(1:32:56) AI Timelines, Regulation & Self-Regulating Systems