18 Episodes

  1. INTRODUCING: MISSING IN ARIZONA

    Published: 9/25/2024
  2. INTRODUCING: IN THE SHADOW OF PRINCETON

    Published: 6/5/2024
  3. COMING SOON: IN THE SHADOW OF PRINCETON

    Published: 5/30/2024
  4. Feed drop: Introducing Firecracker

    Published: 11/14/2023
  5. BONUS: The Watcher

    Published: 11/2/2022
  6. BONUS: Pulling back the curtain

    Published: 7/19/2022
  7. BONUS: Postcards from the edge

    Published: 7/5/2022
  8. A word about season one

    Published: 6/28/2022
  9. Episode 9: Sympathy for the devil

    Published: 6/21/2022
  10. Episode 8: Judgment Day

    Published: 6/14/2022
  11. Episode 7: The old lady and the tabloids

    Published: 6/7/2022
  12. Episode 6: America's Most Wanted

    Published: 5/31/2022
  13. Episode 5: The Talented Mr. List

    Published: 5/24/2022
  14. Episode 4: Mopping up the blood

    Published: 5/17/2022
  15. Episode 3: The man at the train station

    Published: 5/10/2022
  16. Episode 2: The boogeyman of Westfield

    Published: 5/10/2022
  17. Episode 1: The mansion turned morgue

    Published: 5/10/2022
  18. Trailer: Father Wants Us Dead

    Published: 4/29/2022

1 / 1

In 1971, a mild-mannered accountant and Sunday school teacher from New Jersey named John List murders his wife, mother and three children — only to disappear and begin a new life entirely on the other side of the country. Now, two veteran journalists go inside the mind of the killer, learn about the doomed family, and revisit the 18-year-quest to bring List to justice — a saga even more bizarre and twisted than ever previously reported.